Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5

by Mike W

091521B-300x157 Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5In this blog, I will debate two books. Which is the better long-term investment going forward? Let’s pit Tales of Suspense #39 against Fantastic Four #5 and see who comes out on top. One book represents the past, but maybe also the future? The other comic represents the future of the MCU, but in a different light. Both books are from the Silver Age and command high prices on the current market. Lastly, these issues notate very important first appearances of notable characters in the Marvel mythos.

The Rivals

The two comics I am comparing are Tales of Suspense #39 (TOS #39) and Fantastic Four #5 (FF #5). Both issues introduce very important characters in the Marvel universe. Tales of Suspense #39 depicts the first appearance of Iron Man and Fantastic Four #5 notates the first appearance and origin of Doctor Doom.Doctor-Doom-Comic-300x156 Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5

Notably, these issues are currently items #16 & 66 on GoCollect’s Most Popular Silver Age Comic Books for this week as of 09/15/2021. The main reason I chose to compare these books is due to the similar financial values these issues share with each other.

For example, both books graded in a 6.0 have a current FMV of $21,000. In addition, the 8.0 graded value is very close too. The price of TOS #39 is currently at $48,000 and FF #5 is priced at $52,000. It is important to compare books that have similar price ranges when predicting how high can the comic go.

Iron Man’s Rise

Tales_of_Suspense_Vol_1_39-194x300 Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5I am sure this has been said numerous times in regards to the MCU, but I will say it again. The live-action Iron Man #1 is technically the first movie to popularize the current MCU. This has caused at least a chunk of the popularity of the notable character Iron Man and the issue discussed above. Tony Stark, aka Iron Man, carried the MCU through the Infinity Saga from 2008 through 2019. As a result, the character and value rose tremendously. In addition, Robert Downey Jr, the actor who portrayed Iron Man, did a fantastic job in the role and will forever be linked to the character going forward.

Nowadays, fans and collectors still want that piece of history and feeling of nostalgia for this character. The issue is still in demand for collectors, even though the character and actor moved on after the last Avengers movie. The reasons I stated above are enough fuel to keep the price of this issue stable and should slowly increase over time. Remember, “Silver Age” Marvel keys are like a fine wine. They only get more expensive over time, regardless of hype.

Origin of Victor Von Doom – Dr. Doom

Fantastic Four #5DrDoom-202x300 Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5 is a very important key issue for Marvel and their media universe. It notates the first appearance and origin of Victor Von Doom, otherwise known as Doctor Doom. It is also a famed Silver Age comic in the very popular and original Fantastic Four series. Lately, very early issues of this series are scarce in high grades and very pricey. The financial comparisons of this issue to TOS #39 are very similar, but the character has not appeared yet in the MCU.

Doom is heavily rumored to join the MCU in the very near future. The issue is guessing when that will be. Many speculators believe the possible debut will occur in the upcoming Antman 3 movie in 2023. The reason being that the Fantastic Four could make their debut in the movie.

Doctor-Doom-Fantastic-Four-Jack-Kirby-300x150 Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5His ties to many Marvel characters would be a good reason for his long-term growth in the market and in the MCU. His feuds and battles are not tied to one Marvel character. Comic history details altercations with characters such as Namor, Black Panther, Silver Surfer, The Hulk, Thor, The Avengers, and The X-Men.

Inversely, Doom also teams up with characters and can be used in a more positive light as well. He has made temporary partnerships with heroes such as Iron Man, Reed Richards, and Loki. Doom has the versatility to start in the MCU as a “big bad” and end his theatrical run as a hero. Either way, his growth from his first appearance is just beginning.

All in all, both comics have their strong points on who will have the higher value at the end of the day. Both are sure bets for financial stability going forward, as collectors will continue to invest Silver Age Marvel comic key books. The question is, which book has the better growth going forward?

What do you think? Let us know in the comments!

Exciting things are right around the corner! Get ready for all the newest bells and whistles with an upgraded membership to GoCollect PRO!

000080221A_Posters_2-Footer Who ya Got? Tales of Suspense #39 vs Fantastic Four #5

You may also like


Steven Moore September 21, 2021 - 1:19 pm

Good catch. Tales of Suspense 39 all the way–first appearance of a major marvel hero beats first appearance of a villain any day. I wonder how this issue came to be so undervalued?

Mike W September 23, 2021 - 8:59 pm

which issue is under-valued?

Alan Harper September 21, 2021 - 2:46 pm

I have to vote Dr. Doom here – at least for the next 12-24 months as our favorite Latvian seems to pop up everywhere. Ironman I agree will hold value but it will be nostalgia not new buzz. Both will be steady but the upside as to be FF#5.

Mike W September 23, 2021 - 9:00 pm

good points! how much of the value of FF#5 can rise?

Clark Landry September 21, 2021 - 3:21 pm

The Doom book is a better investment. They haven’t used him in the MCU, and he’s easily one of the best Marvel villains. They’ll be using him for ages. Iron Man had his moment – I don’t see a catalyst for this book going higher.

Mike W September 23, 2021 - 9:02 pm

interesting point of view. Do you think TOS 39’s value will start to dip?

stephen bradley September 22, 2021 - 12:34 am

I’m going with FF5…Its older than TOS and less copies on the Census…Another reason might be the future of FF moving into the MCU and Maybe Ironman has already been played out…

Mike W September 23, 2021 - 9:03 pm

Nice to hear! I like your statistics between TOS & FF.

JonG September 22, 2021 - 10:21 pm

Dr. Doom! Awesome character. Iron man is lame. Just a rich guy with fancy gadgets… Marvels equivalent to Batman. Im glad the MCU killed him off.

Mike W September 23, 2021 - 9:03 pm

lol, harsh words, when you mention Stark is dead.

H Switz October 24, 2021 - 1:49 pm

There’s no way FF 5 will ever be a better investment than Suspense 39

Suspense 39 has always been in Overstreets top 10 Silverage books including DC while FF 5 has never cracked the top 10. Don’t get me wrong Doom’s a great character but he will never be on the same popularity level as Iron Man.

Iron man is now a franchise on its own thanks to the movies and will live on for years to come whether he is dead or not. And I’m sure knowing the success of this character in the MCU I don’t believe we have seen the last of him even though it may not be a Robert Downey Jr version.

That said Iron Man is not “lame” wherever you get that from previous poster but everyone has their own opinions

Rant over Suspense 39 will always be the better investment long term due to the better first appearance. FF 5 benefits from being a year older so high grade copies may be harder to find. Probably see a spike if ever a movie gets made.


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: