What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?

by Norman Robinson III

030422B-1024x536 What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?

The Top 20 Silver Age comic book series sold over the last year represent an 83 million dollar market.  The top four book series represent 50% of the SA market in value. This is based on a rolling value over time. This is a scary number until you realize how hard it is to obtain these books profitably even for a savvy speculator.

For instance, the recording-breaking number for Amazing Fantasy #15 in high-grade last year.

eyJidWNrZXQiOiJnb2NvbGxlY3QuaW1hZ2VzLnB1YiIsImtleSI6ImU0N2M3ZjYyLTBlNGYtNDY2Zi1iOTIzLTQ3NjA2N2FiYmQxNy5qcGciLCJlZGl0cyI6eyJyZXNpemUiOnsid2lkdGgiOjYwMH19fQ== What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?

With 83 million dollars in value, the biggest title of the bunch is no surprise; Amazing Spider-Man pulls down 17% of the entire Silver Age Top 20 market value.

The runner-up? “It’s Clobberin’ time, folks!” Yep, the FF dominates the 2nd spot at 13%, and so on.

How can speculators and investors use this chart to better enable their purchases or sales of comic books?

Further, what can we deduce as speculators from this data? Can this SA Top 20 list prove a useful tool?

Top 20 Silver Age Titles (Ongoing) SA Rank Current Percent of SA Mkt
Amazing Spider-Man ’63 1 17.25%
Fantastic Four ’61 2 13.47%
Amazing Fantasy ’62 3 12.48%
X-Men ’63 4 11.99%
Avengers ’63 5 6.31%
Daredevil ’64 6 4.46%
Journey Into Mystery ’52 7 3.76%
Tales of Suspense ’59 8 3.46%
Incredible Hulk ’62 9 3.37%
Silver Surfer ’68 10 2.08%
Stange Tales ’51 11 1.76%
Tales to Astonish ’59 14 1.39%
Showcase ’56 13 1.39%
Batman ’40 12 1.39%
Captain America ’68 16 1.01%
Thor ’66 17 0.98%
Detective Comics ’37 15 0.93%
Brave and the Bold ’55 18 0.90%
Iron Man ’68 19 0.89%
Amazing Spider-Man Annuals 20 0.68%
Rolling Mkt Top 20 Titles SA $83,415,335 Million

eyJidWNrZXQiOiJnb2NvbGxlY3QuaW1hZ2VzLnB1YiIsImtleSI6IjE0MWY5NTlhLWM1OTYtNGJlMC04ZTYzLTMxYmZlYWQzYzZlMC5qcGciLCJlZGl0cyI6eyJyZXNpemUiOnsid2lkdGgiOjYwMH19fQ== What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?The Secret of the Annuals

One interesting side note is that the Amazing Spider-Man Annuals are on this list. They are the very last book title at the 20th but still something to watch out for. I don’t know about you, but I haven’t really gotten into annuals that much. That said,  I do know their value has risen over the last five years. Especially as a standard series becomes harder and harder to find, or is simply priced out of reach. 

The Amazing Spider-Man Annuals represent about half a million dollars in value.  What I find shocking about this is; is that they’re even in there at all! I mean, we’re talking the Top 20 Silver Age books, and annuals are creeping in?

*Note to self: Take a closer look at annuals going forward. Perhaps these annuals are a potential profit center overlooked.

80% of the market is…

Another shocking tidbit is that the top 11 books are all Marvel Comics. Now, I know that DC Comics has started to take off, slowly. But nowhere near the value of Marvel Comics, nor at the same frenzied pace. That said, it’s shocking to see the overweight value in Marvel books.asm-14-198x300 What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?

Furthermore, of the top 20 comics, 16 are Marvel comic books. This means that only four are DC Comics. If you translate this into a percentage base; then 80% of the books are Marvel Comics. Ultimately, this means 80% of this market is probably focused on Marvel. Think about that from a sales perspective. If 100 people walk past your booth at Comic-Con; only 20 of them are looking for DC Comics. Yikes!

Silver Age Fiasco?

My take on this Silver Age fiasco is that Marvel has gotten a tad bit ahead of itself.  Bubble territory?  I don’t think so. But it would not surprise me to see prices declining slightly over the next 2-3 years. 

If you are an investor and buying for the 3-5 year range, this should not impact you too much. However, speculators should be feeling the pulse of this market and not be too overweight in the big four titles if you can help it. 

eyJidWNrZXQiOiJnb2NvbGxlY3QuaW1hZ2VzLnB1YiIsImtleSI6IjI2MDYyN2JmLWM4ZTEtNGJjMi1iM2E4LTQ0NWU1ZjhlYmFhNS5qcGciLCJlZGl0cyI6eyJyZXNpemUiOnsid2lkdGgiOjYwMH19fQ== What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?Conclusion

To be a profitable speculator you need to have one foot in the present, and one foot in the future. Marvel Comics dominate the Silver Age marketplace today. Their comics are still going strong and there seems to be no let-up.

Even their TV shows are pretty decent, so should we throw in the towel and hop on the Marvel mania ride? Not at this point, you want to slowly reduce your Marvel comic inventory to a survivable level and start speculating on the future. 

Yes, I am talking about DC Comics and all those really bad Adventure Comics (just kidding) you pass on your way to the Amazing Spidey bins. 

I think DC Comics will get its time in the sun. However, buying now while it is out of favor is what a smart collector and savvy speculator would do. 

Check out more blogs by Norman!

AAA-Norman-Robinson-footer What are the Top 20 Silver Age Series of the Year?*Any perceived investment advice is that of the freelance blogger and does not constitute investment advice on behalf of GoCollect.

You may also like

4 comments

Dave Stevens March 9, 2022 - 12:58 pm

Annuals aren’t a different title. They’re Amazing Spider-Man or whatever title they are, and should have been included with their respectove titles.

Reply
SpiderSinatra March 9, 2022 - 5:27 pm

Nice article. Are you planning to do Bronze and Copper similarly?

Reply
Steven Moore March 10, 2022 - 1:53 pm

Great idea–I’ve been wondering when GoCollect would use the data this way. Presumably, now that you have the proper weights, the next step is to come up with an overall comic book market index, like the DJIA, to track changes over time in the market. Should be interesting!

Reply
Mark March 12, 2022 - 3:55 pm

Just have ta say “Make mine Marvel” numbers don’t lie. I’ve been collecting since the 70’s n you can say what you want but Marvel is King, and I don’t see it changing, DC ruled at one time but not anymore and if you combine that with oh I don’t know,DISNEY, oh they did,that’s right can you say Brilliant. The presence of Disney combined w/ Marvel is about as good as it gets. DC may slowly creep its way up but it’s never gonna be the Juggernaut that it once was. Although DC has come out w/ a few decent flicks, they just have not kept up w/ Marvels movies, or the pace of which Marvel is at.seeing returns on some DC investments compared to Marvel hmmm you said it yourself 80% compared to 20% That’s 8 people looking to buy my Marvels compared to 2 lookin for some old DC glory day books. Its more than just the Marvel or DC logo it’s how they approach and do things and ever since Stan brought in the Marvel age well let’s just say… Nuf Said

Reply

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: