Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint Photos

by Take Root

DC15-220x300 Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint PhotosHave you ever been on the hunt for a particular book and you seem to keep coming across the same listing over and over again? There’s a reason for that. Here is my guide to spotting a comic scam.

Unfortunately, wherever money trades hands, there can be abuse. The comic book community is no exception.

I’ve been on the hunt for a couple particular books lately, Silver Surfer #1, Return of Wolverine #2 (Moebius Variant), and more. There’s always more. Yet, I keep coming across the same comic books by the same sellers with the same photos and the same descriptions. The strangest part of the whole thing is, well, they sell every week.

Spotting a Comic Scamboris-197x300 Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint Photos

It’s not always easy to spot one, but you can get that intuitive caution in your gut, that spidey-sense, as we comic nerds would call it. If the deal looks too good to be true, then it is. It ALWAYS is. In my constant internet perusals, I’ve often found books priced to trick buyers. Maybe it’s a facsimile with everything leading you to believe it’s the real thing. The price is cheap for an NM New Mutants #98, and everything looks good. So you do a once over of the pictures, check out the corners and spine, and forget to read the $3.99 in the price. Maybe you spent ten times what you could have bought it for at your LCS.

Is this a perfect example? No, but it happens. We as speculators can get so caught up in the deal of the century that we miss the obvious elements right in front of us. It also doesn’t help that facsimiles, for example, are sometimes being marketed as the real thing. (Ads will often write “Be Sure to Read the Whole Listing Before Bidding” and then hide whatever defect at the bottom of the description. Whenever you see that, run.)

feature-205x300 Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint PhotosShill Bidding

This is fake bidding. The seller, or the friend of the seller, will set up an unconnected account to raise the price of an item. It’s totally against all auction websites policy and very not o-k if you have any sense of moral integrity. This is why you see the same items sell over and over. Sellers will shill bid their items to make more money. But a lot of times they overshoot. If they think someone is really interested in an item, then they will go back and forth. A lot of times, they end up not selling the item and have to relist it back on the website. If you’ve seen the comic sell in the last month and yet magically reappear for sale, DO NOT BUY IT. Take your business elsewhere.

Bid Retractions

A quick note, sometimes shill bids will be raised and then retracted at the last second. It’s hard to do, but crooks are crooks, and they’ll do anything to make a buck. If you were losing an auction in the last ten seconds, it means you lost it. If all of a sudden you win it by a miracle, it means someone took you to your limit and then backed off just a step to juice you for everything you were worth. Report this to whatever website you are using.

2nd Chance Offers

This is unique to eBay (I think) but should be covered. This is another way for the seller to cover their butts in a shill bid. If they raise it past your max bid and end up winning the auction with their fake account, then guess what? They’re going to offer you a second chance. (How sweet of them.) If you get a 2nd Chance Offer within a couple hours of the auction, go on your way. The book will be back on the website soon enough and the seller will be looking to do the same thing to the next unsuspecting buyer.

Blue Tint Photos

There is a nonprofit company selling on auction sites that uses a blue tint photo in almost all of their auctions. (I really want to write the name of their alleged nonprofit, but won’t.) This isn’t illegal, or against any site rules, but it can drastically change the appearance of a comic book. Light colors look brighter and dark colors look darker. Almost always these will show up as looking way better than whatever grade is on them.

And that’s the whole point. They’ve been photo-shopped to make you think it’s nicer than it really is. The worst part is that it works. Blue tint photos almost always sell for more than comics with regular photos. So don’t buy them.

blue-192x300 Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint Photos batman-no-blue-225x300 Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint Photos

Conclusion of Spotting a Comic Scam

I’ll add some more tips in the coming weeks about spotting a comic scam, but it’s important to keep an eye out for what you can. This is a money-making industry and the tertiary market can be brutal if you let your guard down. My best advice would be to stay away from sellers that do this or report them. If we all did, then they would have to change their ways. This fights against inflation, market bubbles, and good old fashioned corruption.

Stay vigilant,

adventure-207x300 Not Getting Scammed: Shill Bidding and Blue Tint Photos

GoCollect is the #1 comic book price guide for tracking sales data of all graded comic books in real-time. Fair market values are now at your fingertips. Check out all the features at

You may also like


Josh June 15, 2020 - 2:25 pm

Wow. People suck. I’m so glad I read your post though. Much appreciated!

Ryan Kirksey June 15, 2020 - 2:38 pm

Jake, this is fantastic stuff. Loved reading this!

Rick S June 16, 2020 - 2:57 am

This is an excellent write up, thanks for doing this, I’ve been telling the folks in my collecting circle for awhile about those tactics as I know I’ve been tapped out by shillers before on more than one occasion.
And the ‘blue tint’ seller IS breaking rules every time there’s a website photo on their ‘bay listing’ stating to buy it tax free at where they support their NOW-single moms. Referring to their web address is against the rules as it encourages a customer to buy outside Ebay for less and I would report a listing to Ebay every time I see them.

J June 16, 2020 - 4:17 am

Definitely. The certain ‘blue tint’ seller is breaking other rules. It’s really a shame they are still active on eBay. If we continue to report these sellers then they are going to have to change their ways eventually.

Paul Larsen June 15, 2020 - 4:32 pm

Great article, very informative.
Of my large collection , I’ve only bought 4 books ever from EBay; much prefer conventions or Canadian Auction Websites to meet people within our fantastic community.

Ivan R Roliz June 15, 2020 - 6:38 pm

Thanks for posting this! It feels like this happening more now that the economy is suffering. People who are desperate and they will to to many lengths to attain their goals.

Joseph Taylor June 15, 2020 - 7:46 pm

I reported A case shill bidding to ebay it was obvious an account with 0 purchases was bidding against me,they agreed.
however they did not lower price back to the pre shill bid price so be wary

Sweet Lou June 20, 2020 - 9:47 am

Strongly suggest checking out the following thread on the CGC forum about the seller nobody seems to want to name:

This guy deserves to be run out of business, spread the word!

NAMOR June 20, 2020 - 7:31 pm

Great article!!!

I lost a bidding battle to an eBay shill a few weeks ago. Thank goodness I did. Because I saw the same seller re-listed the same comic a few days later. (Crook!)

So this time I did nothing, no bids at all. I waited till the last 7 seconds, and sniped it. Pow! Got the book for 70% less. It’s a very rare HTF book I really wanted.

The idea was that I didn’t contribute to the price going sky high, by bidding up through the week. I was the only bidder.

Sniping is my absolute favorite way of buying. Plus there is a built in excitement, that adds to the thrill.


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: