Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

by Douglas Ohlandt

011823D-1024x536 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime AuctionMy Comic Shop held their latest Prime Auction January 9 through January 13. While these auctions are at a slightly lower level than Heritage, ComicConnect, or Hakes auctions, there are typically some big sales of comics of note. Let’s take a look at some of the highlights from the auction.

Archie Reigns

Archie1-217x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

Archie Andrews’ first issue of his self-titled series, Archie Comics #1, was the big sale on the first day of the auction. A CBCS graded copy with a restored grade of 8.5 sold for $12,101. This copy had never previously had a recorded sale. To put this sale in perspective, the last time an unrestored 8.5 CBCS graded copy sold was in 2015 for $12,422.

There is one unrestored copy in the 8.5 grade in the CGC census, the highest grade. It last sold in 2011 for $167,300. Clearly, any sale of Archie Comics #1 is a big deal, but I’m really curious to see how high that top graded CGC copy could go.

Captain Marvel & the Marvel Family

MarvelFam1-216x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

There were a few sales of Captain Marvel related comics in the auction. The big one was Marvel Family #1, the first appearance of Black Adam, of which a 5.5 and a 1.5 graded copy both sold. The 5.5 sold for $10,600, a record in the grade.

The last sale was in 2019 for $5,250. The 1.5 sold for $2,650. That’s down 26% from the previous sale and continues the downward trajectory for this book in this grade.

CapMarvelAdv1-212x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

A CBCS 2.0 graded copy of Captain Marvel Adventures #1 also sold in the auction. The winning bid was $5,878. The last time a CBCS graded 2.0 copy of this comic sold was in January 2021 for $7,680, so we’re seeing a 23% decline here. Neither of the two CGC graded 2.0 copies has a recorded sale.

Timely Sales

YoungAllies15-195x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

A few Golden Age Timely books sold in the auction, a 6.5 graded The Human Torch #9 ($2,705), a 2.5 graded Marvel Mystery Comics #33 ($903), and a 6.0 graded Young Allies #15 ($1,100). The Young Allies #15 sale marks a 22% increase from the previous sale for $900 in a December 2021 ComicConnect auction. However, it was a pretty steep drop of 37% for The Human Torch #9 from its all-time high set in the November 2021 Heritage auction for $4,320.

Analytical data is lacking for Marvel Mystery Comics #33; the only previous sale for $335 was in 2007.

Matt Baker Sales

Zoot14a-207x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

There were a number of sales of comics featuring Matt Baker covers and/or interior artwork. The biggest by far was an 8.0 graded copy of Zoot #14(a), which went for $2,525.

The previous sale in this grade was in a January 2018 Heritage auction for $1,135. That’s more than double the previous price and nearing the FMV for a 9.4 graded copy – $2,800.

Marvel First Issues and Appearances Sales

X-Men1-198x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

Marvel Silver Age first issues and first appearances made the biggest splashes on the second and third days of the auction. A 4.5 graded copy of X-Men #1 sold for $12,101.

That’s in line with some of the steep declines we’ve seen in this book over the past year, although it’s interesting to note that it’s higher than the previous two sales of $10,300 (November 6) and a slashed $13,000 (December 25).

TTA27-202x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

A restored 1.5 graded copy of Fantastic Four #1 sold for $6,400. Of course, that’s down from the last sale of an unrestored copy: $10,105 in an August eBay auction. Of comparable vintage, a 6.0 graded copy of Hank Pym’s first appearance in Tales to Astonish #27 sold for $6,576.

This marks a drop for this book that now moves it lower than sales in this grade prior to 2021. It’s only a 15% decrease from the December Heritage auction sale for $7,800, but it’s definitely a marker for those tracking when the gains of the past two years are completely erased.

ToS57-200x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

We’re seeing similar declines in values for Daredevil #1. A 6.0 graded copy sold in the auction for $5,322, and it’s the first time since 2020 that prices in this grade have fallen below $6,000. We may, however, be seeing bit of leveling in the values for Iron Man #1, as evidenced by the sale of a 7.5 for $1,200. That’s a notch above the average of the past four sales of this book in this grade – $1,162.

The same can’t be said for the 7.5 graded copy of Tales of Suspense #57, the first appearance of Hawkeye. The $1,401 sale continued the nosedive for this book. It’s down 23% from its previous sale of $1,830 on November 14, and down a whopping 64% from its December 2021 peak of $3,840.

Marvel Bronze Age Sales – A Mixed Bag

IncHulk181-201x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

Marvel keys dominated Bronze Age sales from the auction. The inevitable Incredible Hulk #181 had a few sales. Curiosity note: can anyone remember a big auction without a copy of Incredible Hulk #181 included?

The highest was a CBCS 8.0 graded copy selling for $6,419. That’s down from the last sale of a CBCS 8.0: $8,401 in a May 2021 eBay auction, but in line with recent CGC 8.0 sales.

ASM129-201x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

The trend continued with the Punisher’s first appearance in Amazing Spider-Man #129. A 9.0 graded copy sold for $3,100, very much in line with sales in this grade over the past few weeks. This comic is down an incredible 77% from it’s all-time high in this grade of a slashed $15,000 set in April 2022.

WWBN32-195x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

Bucking the trend was the $2,025 sale of a 7.5 graded copy of Werewolf by Night #32. This book had been in freefall since the end of the Moon Knight Disney+ series. This sale, however, marks the first sale in this grade above $2,000 since June.

Other Highlights from the Auction

SWCW1-193x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

On the Copper Age/Modern side, a 9.8 graded copy of Star Wars: The Clone Wars #1 sold for $1,776. Sales on this book have been bouncing up and down between a low of $1,700 and a high of $2,300 over the past month.

This sale is a little on the low end of that range but it’s hard to tell whether the trend is upward or downward. A 9.8 graded variant version, limited to 1,000 copies, of Star Wars: The Clone Wars #1 also sold in the auction for $5,900.

Usagi1-193x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

A 9.8 graded copy of Usagi Yojimbo #1 with verified Stan Sakai signature sold for just $785. You may remember this comic reaching astronomical heights as high as a slashed $3,500 back in July 2021. It’s fallen remarkably since.

BatmanAdv12-197x300 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction

And finally, a 9.6 graded copy of Batman Adventures #12 continued its roller coaster ride with a $990 sale. This Copper Age bellwether seems to be in a constant state of flux, as befitting a more modern book with over 8,000 graded copies. Sales over the past month have been over $1,000 in this grade after mid-December sales that went as low as $798.

Do you want to see more auction highlights? Let us know below.

AAA-Footer-CL-3 Highlights from the My Comic Shop January Prime Auction*Any perceived investment advice is that of the freelance blogger and does not represent advice on behalf of GoCollect.

You may also like

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: